Jump to content
Forum Cinema em Cena

Austrália


texer
 Share

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 500
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Members

Mais uma crítica negativa.

Movie Review: Australia (2008)

A major miscalculation if there ever was one

BY: Brad Brevet | November 24th 2008 at 12:15 AM

 

Nicole Kidman and Hugh Jackman in Australia
Photo: 20th Century Fox

Australia is a film that is a drastic miscalculation on the part of director/co-writer Baz Luhrmann. This much stalled project once starred Russell Crowe, then Heath Ledger and ultimately Hugh Jackman and has taken forever to get to the screen, and once you it you will know why. This is a daunting effort as Luhrmann hopes to make a film as grand as the likes of Gone With the Wind and Lawrence of Arabia all while telling a love story mixed in with the tragic racial policies imposed on half-white/half-Aboriginal children as they are stripped from their families in an effort to “breed the black out of them”. The idea is as offensive as it sounds, but in Australia’s attempts to make sure the film is as much a love story as it is (more, actually) a tale of a “stolen generation” it loses its focus and turns into a boring trip through the Outback that seemed to pass by at a snail’s pace.

The film begins in 1939 as the voice of a young boy begins introducing us to the story in broken English. The violence against the Aboriginal people is quickly realized as well as early introductions to our two main characters Lady Sarah Ashley (Nicole Kidman) and a man simply known as The Drover (Hugh Jackman). Why’s he called The Drover? Because he is what he does… plain and simple. Sarah Ashley, however, is more than she initially appears to be as this stuffy aristocrat comes from London to Australia to confront her presumed-to-be-cheating husband at Faraway Downs, a remote outpost in Darwin, Australia.

Things change once Sarah arrives to find her husband has been murdered and the outpost is in ruin and damn near worthless as Aussie cattle baron King Carney (Bryan Brown) and his crony, the film’s primary villain, Neil Fletcher (David Wenham) have run the land ragged and have been stealing their cattle. Sarah can either sell the land at a loss or try and work it herself; an option most would laugh at considering her refined nature and the dusty prerequisite for working such a savage land. The twist in the story arrives in the form of Nullah (Brandon Walters) a young half-white/half-Aboriginal child Sarah takes to mothering and with the help of The Drover believes the land is salvageable.

From this point, the film becomes a story of the love between Sarah, The Drover and Nullah as they form a strange family unit. Their story combines with the territorial war against Fletcher as he hungers for power and Carney’s place as king of the land all while the battle of race relations and search for one’s inner self acts as the film’s thread line. All this plays while the threat of World War II is in the background and ultimately serving as the film’s climax. Epic is an understatement, but with so many hats in the air none of them are able to be caught as the story gets caught up in the middle ground and only to try and find its legs in its multiple climactic moments when I was already too weary to care.

Scenes between Lady Ashley and The Drover are never interesting until the final moments when a problem is either reconciled or expanded upon. Their love is realized in the smaller more personal aspects of the film, once the grand scope of Baz’s vision is stripped away and he remembers this is a story and not a visual exercise. Luhrmann got a lot out of both Kidman and Jackman when the script asked for it, but unfortunately it doesn’t ask often enough as the majority of the film is so uninteresting you can almost feel the seconds tick away.

A lot of praise has been shouldered onto young Brandon Walters and I am not sure why exactly. As a first time actor he does just fine, but nothing to warrant anything more than a pat on the back and a “Good job” at the end of the day. The Nullah character is so cliché and contrived there is no heart left. The only emotion comes when the downright laughable villain, Fletcher, continues to refer to Nullah as a “Creamy” over, and over, and over, and over again with a snarl in his voice as he mimics the character he played in Zack Snyder’s 300 with deft efficiency. Fletcher is a character so empty and so sickly laughable it hurts to watch him on screen. I kept hoping a stray boomerang would end his involvement in the film as each scene he is in only gets worse and worse. Meanwhile you have Nullah running around screaming at Sarah Ashley yelling, “Ms. Boss, Ms. Boss, Ms. Boss!” If Luhrmann had a point here I wish he would have included it in subtitles as he explains the film’s true intentions just before the credits roll because the non-stop pandering was insufferable.

The only place to find any enjoyment in this film is to take in its beauty, but that is to be expected with anything involving Luhrmann. However, if you are to do that it will take you even further out of the film as CG set pieces and attention to detail make the film feel as artificial as it actually is. Beautiful? Yes, but not without distraction.

I can’t help but feel bad not liking this film knowing how important it is to Luhrmann and how much he loves his native land, but to take any pity on the film for those reasons would be a lie. Australia is a mess of a picture with hardly a handful of entertaining scenes. It’s billed as a love story, but you will soon realize the love story isn’t even really the film’s true intention and on top of that it isn’t even all that romantic as much as it is obvious. In the end I took nothing away from this film, but I am sure it would make a decent picture book.

GRADE: D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members
Não' date=' as outras eram musicas do musical do Bob Fosse.

A única música original de Chicago era "Move On", cantada nos créditos.
[/quote']

 

Não acho, adoro "Move On", acho, inclusive, melhor que várias como "Razzle Dazzle", "Mister Cellophane" e "All I Care About". Tem uma música que ficou de fora, chamada "Class", lindíssima, cantada pela Zeta e Queen Latifah.

 

Sobre "Austrália" as boas críticas são mornas, e as ruins são calorosas e detestam o filme, ou seja, não vejo mais nenhuma chance para prêmios. Depois de quarta e da bilheteria saberemos se existe alguma chance, bem.

 

Rotten atualizado: 65% 13 freshs, e 7 rottens. :(
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Rotten atualizado: 62%04

 

Parece q nossa única chance é nas bilheterias...

Vamos torcer para Austrália derrubar Twilight de vez e ficar uma duas semanas consecutivas na liderança! rsrsrsrsrssrsrsrs

Pan, vc entendeu errado!!!!!!!!!!

06

Música Original é um termo utilizado pela Academia para as músicas de um filme que foram feitos especialmente para ele, só elas são indicadas na categoria Melhor Canção do Oscar, entende?

Não é originalidade de qualidade!!

Tb acho todas as músicas de Chicago fabulosas, mas a única q foi composta especialmente para o filme e naum vinha do espetáculo da Broadway era Move On q foi indicada.
texer2008-11-24 19:24:40
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Eu sei texer, eu falei que eu acho "Move On", uma música original feita para o Oscar, melhor que algumas da montagem original da Broadway, porque o Bruno disse que todas as músicas que ele lembra do filme são melhores que "Move On"; não acho.

Ah, entendi a confusão. Eu queria quotar essa frase do Bruno "Então foi isso. Que eu me lembre todas as canções incluídas no filme são melhores que "Move On".", e quotei a sua fala texer, aí gerou a confusão, entende?

 

Só falta "Austrália" ficar Rotten no site, aí morro. ¬¬

 

É, ficou para a próxima, de novo, Kidman. :(

 

E sobre "Twiilight", dúvido 06. Acho que "Austrália" nem chega ao primeiro lugar, como estréia quarta, "Twiilight" deve ficar de novo em primeiro, pelo menos na semana. 04
pantalaimon2008-11-24 19:45:19
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

 

Já nem leio mais, pan... Se naum elas vão me causar profunda depressão...

 

Só acho q boa parte delas são inconsistentes pois apontam como falha do filme os diversos clichês do gênero,sendo q é óbvia a proposta do Luhrmann em trazer um filme com todos estes clichês, uma espécie de homenagem a uma escola clássica com a marca do Baz Luhrmann. Se a proposta é essa, como isso pode ser apontado como defeito?

 

Acho q a imprensa, em função do Oscar do ano passado, entrou numa de o q tem qualidade no cinema deve conter, obrigatoriamente, o compromisso com o inusitado, a abordagem que rompa padrões... Claro q isso é fantástico, como também o é o cinema que nos faz sonhar... Sei lá... Histórias que fascinam as platéias há anos, mas q sempre nos emociona, como é o caso dos épicos românticos, um gênero q, de regra, é avacalhado pelos cinéfilos como sinal de um pretensioso entendimento sobre a sétima arte.

 

Duvido muito q vá detestar este filme, naum só pela Nicole Kidman, mas principalmente por Baz Luhrmann, cineasta q passei a admirar em Romeu + Julieta.

 

texer2008-11-25 20:20:12

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Pessoal, leiam este texto publicado no The Envelope. Me pareceu um ponto de vista bem interessante...

 

Hmmm . . . are Oscars pundits underestimating 'Australia'?

 

 

 

 

Australia_nicole_kidman

 

It was obvious that the audience was impressed by "The Curious Case of Benjamin Button"

when it screened last night at the Museum of Modern Art in New York.

Afterward, a truly curious scene occurred. Two academy members said how

much they enjoyed the pic, but when asked what Oscar contender they

like the most so far, they gushed, "'Australia'!"

 

That's significant because quite a few Oscar pundits are downplaying

"Australia's" odds of even getting nominated for best picture. I think

that's a mistake. They're buying into what film critics think, a pack

of wolfmen who always attack brazenly sentimental fare, especially if

showcased in a chick flick. Academy members think differently. Like

academy member Oprah Winfrey,

who's over the moon about it, raving to her TV viewers, "Have I got a

movie for you!" Remember, movies with a strong rooting factor can still

be nominated even if a majority of Oscar voters don't even put

"Australia" anywhere on their ballot when ranking their five choices

for best pic. The preferential ballot is odd like that. No, I don't

think "Australia" can win best picture, but I think we shouldn't write

off the possibility that it could snag a top bid.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Vi três vídeos, e gostei. Pois é, quem sabe o filme aparece no Oscar. Eu, sinceramente, adoro torcer pela Kidman, Baz, gosto dos dois, e sei que o filme é bom, confio nele. Se será indicado ao Oscar ou não é outra história. O que eu realmente quero, mais que premiações, de verdade, é o sucesso, nos EUA, do filme, seria ótimo para a Kidman, ela precisa, como atriz comercial que é, também, de um sucesso por lá. Amanhã saberemos. pantalaimon2008-11-26 00:31:28

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Naum é tão fácil contabilizar naum, pan... rsrsrsrsrsrsrsrsrs

Eles devem demorar um pouquinho para divulgar... Só deve sair uma resposta mesmo, durante o fim de semana, é o q normalmente acontece. Talvez por se tratar de um feriado de Ação de Graças, saia alguma prévia na sexta-feira.

Mas muita genter do meio tava prevendo q o Four Chritmases com a Reese Whiterspoon e o Vince Vaughn ocouparia o primeiro lugar ou entaum o Twilight novamente. Eles acreditam q Austrália fique em segundo e q arrecade cerca de 37 a 40 Milhões este fim de semana...

Sei lá...

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Não, mas hoje sai no site do Boxoffice a bilheteria de ontem, eles sempre atualizam, hoje de noite sai. Só queria saber a de ontem mesmo.

 

E na Austrália?Tenta descobrir como foi lá. Você sabe quando estréia na Inglaterra?Se a premiere é dia 10, deve ser só em dezembro, certo?
pantalaimon2008-11-27 15:50:52
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share

Announcements


×
×
  • Create New...